Skip to Main Content
Buffalo's Best Grill and Catering logo topBuffalo's Best Grill and Catering logo scroll
  • (716)-202-1270
  • tony@buffalosbestgrill.com
  • 3700 Southwestern Boulevard , Orchard Park
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
    CATERING MENU CATERING INQUIRY CATERING SERVICES
  • PARTIES
  • JOBS
  • ORDER
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
Buffalo's Best Grill and Catering logo topBuffalo's Best Grill and Catering logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • DRINKS
  • SPECIALS
  • EVENTS
  • CATERING
  • PARTIES
  • JOBS
  • ORDER
  • CATERING MENU
  • CATERING INQUIRY
  • CATERING SERVICES

Our Menu

MenuSunday Omelet Station

Appetizers

Big Bavarian Pretzel photo

Big Bavarian Pretzel

$14.00
Large pretzel twist served with queso blanco.
Fried Pickle Spears photo

Fried Pickle Spears

$9.00
Hand battered pickle spears served with a side of dill sauce.
Chicken Wing Dip photo

Chicken Wing Dip

$16.00
A spicy chicken and hot sauce mixture with fresh tortilla chips and pita.
Italian Tomato Pie photo

Italian Tomato Pie

$8.00
Focaccia bread baked with tomato sauce and traditional Italian spices and Romano cheese served with a dollop of ricotta cheese and olive oil
Stuffed Peppers photo

Stuffed Peppers

$15.00/Traditional
$16.00/Italian
Large banana peppers filled with a cream cheese, garlic and fresh herbs, topped with a garlic aioli or Italian stuffed peppers topped with an Italian sausage parm sauce and mozzarella

Spinach Artichoke Dip

$14.00
Baby spinach, artichoke hearts, garlic, cream cheese, toasted panko crumbs, and pita points.

Queso and Nachos

$6.00/Add Taco Chicken
Nacho chips piled high and topped with our house queso, diced tomatoes, and jalapenos.
Beef on Weck Eggrolls photo

Beef on Weck Eggrolls

$16.00
Sliced roast beef with sauteed onions and kimmelweck wrapped in a crispy eggroll served with a side of horsey sauce and au jus.

Pizza and Things

Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza photo

Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza

$18.00/Medium
$22.00/Large
each additional topping $2 (mushroom, onion, peppers, etc.)

Buffalo's Best Wings

$17.00/single
Hot, medium, mild, BBQ, Sicilian, Italian, Willies BBQ sauce, or garlic parmesan

Chicken Fingers

$15.00/Five
$23.00/Ten
Served with French Fries and your choice of sauce (hot, med, mild, bbq)

Not Your Average Pizza Log

$17.00
Thinly rolled dough stuffed with garlic, ricotta cheese, pepperoni and mozzarella cheese • Modifications: Banana Pepper | Black Olive | Garlic | Garlic Crust | Green Olives | Italian Sausage | Mozzarella | Mushrooms | Onions | Pepperoni | Ricotta | Sweet Pepper | Tomato

Salads

Add Protein: Grilled Chicken - $6 | Grilled Shrimp -$9 | Cajun Grouper- $10 | Chicken fingers - $7 | Steak- $8 • Dressings: Ranch | Thousand Islands | Italian | Blue Cheese | French | Rasp Ving • All Adds: Onions | Tomatoes | Cheddar | Fried Chicken | Romano | Croutons | Feta | Olives | Pepperonchini | Oranges | Almonds | Gorgonzola | Cucumber

Pistachio Salad

$11.00
A lettuce blend topped with tomatoes, goat cheese, roasted pistachios, red onion, and craisins served with raspberry vinaigrette.

Caesar Salad

$8.00
Chopped romaine tossed with Romano cheese, croutons and an anchovy cream dressing

Buffalo's Best Chef Salad

$8.00
Romaine and spring mix topped with grape tomatoes, black olives, red onion, cucumber, cheddar cheese and chic peas • Add Protein: Grilled Chicken | Grilled Shrimp | Cajun Grouper
Cobb Salad photo

Cobb Salad

$12.00
Chopped hearty greens with tomatoes, bacon, cheddar cheese, gorgonzola, egg, and pimento cheese

Gourmet Burgers

Meat Temps: Rare | Med. Rare | Medium | Med. Well | Well Done • Choice of Cheese: American | Cheddar | Pepper Jack | Provolone | Swiss • Modifications: Bacon | Cheddar | Lettuce | Tomato | Onion • All Adds: Onions | Tomatoes | Cheddar | Fried Chicken | Romano | Croutons | Feta | Olives | Pepperonchini | Oranges | Almonds | Gorgonzola | Cucumber • Choose your side: Fries | Slaw | Gouda Mac

Bacon Cheddar Burger photo

Bacon Cheddar Burger

$19.00
Classic burger piled with bacon and cheddar cheese

Whiskey Flazed Burger

$19.00
10 oz burger with suateed onions, banana peppers, and pepper jack cheese with a whiskey bbq glaze

The Classic Cheeseburger

$16.00
10 oz steak burger topped with your choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion served on a Cosotanzo roll

House Specialties

Buffalo Beef Dip

$18.00
Thinly sliced roast beef dipped in au jus on a toasted hoagie roll with mozzarella cheese and served with and a side of horseradish and au jus
Cowboy Reuben photo

Cowboy Reuben

$18.00
Smoked flank steak with a banana pepper, coleslaw, pepper jack cheese and BBQ sauce on rye
Grouper Reuben photo

Grouper Reuben

$19.00
Blackened grouper filet on grilled rye bread with Swiss Cheese, Thousand Island dressing, and coleslaw

Chicken BLT

$16.00
Grilled chicken breast on toasted white bread with bacon, cheese, lettuce, and tomato with a chipotle mayo
Open Prime Rib Sandwich photo

Open Prime Rib Sandwich

$22.00
Tender sliced prime rib on toasted Italian bread with a stuffed pepper, provolone, aioli • Meat Temps: Rare | Med. Rare | Medium | Med. Well | Well Done

Fried Bologna

$11.00
Sliced German style bologna with carmelized onions and pimento cheese spread on a toasted roll

Meatball Bomber

$15.00
Traditional meatball hoagie topped with house parm sauce and mozzarella cheese
Greek Pita photo

Greek Pita

$10.00
A toasted pita pocket filled with lettuce, tomato, red onion, black olives, feta cheese, and Greek dressing. Add cucumber $2, Chicken $7, Shrimp $9
Beef on Weck photo

Beef on Weck

$17.00
Thinly sliced roast beef on a kimmelweck roll with a side of au jus and horseradish

Chicken Salad Sandwich

$11.00
Grilled chicken salad witha cranberries and herbs, served on a toasted croissant with iceburg lettuce

Fresh Chop Hoagie

$16.00/Chicken
$18.00/Steak
Fresh chopped chicken or steak with sauteed onions, peppers, and topped with melted cheese.

Night Plates

Gouda Mac & Cheese photo

Gouda Mac & Cheese

$11.00
A rich creamy Gouda cheese sauce with elbows topped with cheddar cheese. Add Chicken fingers $7 | Add steak $8 | Add both $9

Sirlion Filet

$24.00
8 oz filet of sirloin on a bed of sweet potato mashed and grilled vegetables with a Jack Daniel's reduction and fried onions.

Coconut Lime Shrimp

$19.00
A creamy coconut and lime sauce with tiger shrimp over white rice and topped with fresh chopped cilantro

Lemon Chicken

$17.00
Lemon pepper chicken breast served over cilantro lime rice mixed with grilled vegetables

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$16.00
Spaghetti topped with our house parm sauce and three homemade meatballs, finished with parmesan and herb
Cajun Alfredo photo

Cajun Alfredo

$12.00
Cajun broccoli alfredo with Farfalle Pasta | Grilled Chicken $6 | Chicken Fingers $7 | Steak $8 | Shrimp $9 | Blackened Grouper $10

Kids Menu

Choose your Side: Fries | Slaw | Gouda Mac +$4.00 | Side Salad +$1.00

Kids Flatbread

$6.99

Kids Grilled Cheese

$6.99

Kids Pasta w/ Meatballs

$6.99

Kids Burger

$6.99

Kids Fingers

$6.99

Kids Mac & Cheese

$6.99

Sides

Soup

$3.00/Cup
$5.00/Bowl

Gouda Mac

$4.00
Side of rich creamy Gouda cheese sauce with elbows and cheddar cheese

Baked Potato

$3.00

Rice

$3.00

French Fries

$4.00

Desserts

Peanut Butter Bomb photo

Peanut Butter Bomb

$6.00

Apple Pie

$6.00

Chocolate Eclair

$4.00
Sponge Candy Cheese Cake photo

Sponge Candy Cheese Cake

$6.00

Cupcake

$3.00
Banana Cream Pie photo

Banana Cream Pie

$6.00

Join us every Sunday from 10 am - 1 pm for our delicious omelets. You can pick and choose your desired meats and vegetables to stuff your omelet!

Omelet Station

Select from the following ingredients for your omelet: sausage, bacon, ham, mushrooms, peppers, cheese, onions, spinach, tomatoes, and jalapenos.

Omelet Station photo

Omelet Station

$10.00
Select from the following ingredients for your omelet: sausage, bacon, ham, mushrooms, peppers, cheese, onions, spinach, tomatoes, and jalapenos.
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs